Mafia

[Cheezdude]

I'm very confident Silver is mafia.

I will protect Saber. ^^

[Saber Knight]

I'm very confident Silver is mafia.

I will protect Saber. ^^

Yay ^^

And, just another thing to add, the mafia would have wanted to take out Silver if he were the spy. Since Silver isn't dead (yet), it's highly probable he's the mafia.

[Phonox]

Unless, of course, the Mafia deduced that if Silver was left unharmed, blame would fall on him and a great ally to the game(you just lost) would die.

[Silver]

Yeah, I was actually kinda surprised I wasn't dead, too.

Well, I... can't tell you what to think, but... I do hope you'll consider the fact that I tried to take suspicion off of Gar for an unknown reason and the very next round, he was proved innocent.

Just thought I'd get that out there.

For now, for lack of anything better to guess, I'll go with Saber.

[PoikSpirit]

Yeah... I actually also have very good reason to believe that Phonox isn't the mafia... If at all possible I'd like to avert that bandwagon, too.

Now, I'm really not sure, but... I don't like Sira's random accusations or bandwagon starting. For now, I'm voting Siranae.

Why, thank you spy!

I vote Siranae.

Unless Siranae is pronounced differently, I believe Cheez just rhymed. Is there a rhyming theory?

Updated charges:

Phonox: For posting first, posting an unremarkable remark, and claiming that Gar and myself were not normal citizens fully knowing that we in fact are not normal, being a witch and/or wizard, being different which is punishable by media attacks, and attempting suicide by mass vote.
Saber: For a one word post of accusation, being silent most of the time, being lazy, using Josiah's logic without giving it back (I know you came up with it on your own (supposedly)), and the attempting of redemption by logic addition.
Josiah: For the assistance of misused logic, knowing too much about old video games, being killed after being saved and somehow still being alive, shoving a bandwagon in Sira's face again, sticking to Saber, possible misuse of adhesives, and being the administrator. He must be reading the PMs to find out what the Doctor is sending so that he can mess with our heads.
Silver: For the bandwagon altercation upon Innocent possibly with the knowledge of her Kaidace, for the misuse of participles that start with 'w,' using logic (which is condemnable in a Mafia game), anti-bandwagon propaganda, trying to save a suicidal loon, and being Silver aka awesome.
Gar: For the association of murder methods to logic when it is fully know that the narrator picks, addressing Provolone in his statement, being chosen as a bandwagon target, pretending to not get defensive, buying Sims 3, hesitating in a emergency, bandwagon construction, giving wax lips to a rhino, and promptly dieing thereafter possibly by side effect of the last offense.
Poik: For posting first, eliminating a poodle named Rabid Poodle, almost voting for himself again, accusing Silver of being awesome, the blind following of the blind following of accusation of spy conspiracy, making references to Monkey Island only a few people will get, coping out on a vote, and being Poik. Seriously, that kid creeps me out.
Cheez: For blind followings of the previous posters, accusations of spy conspiracy, use of third person, hesitation in a war zone, claiming that Poik could help in the slightest, using because as the first word in a sentence and forgetting the necessary comma (grammar theory!), rhyming (rhyming theory *sanwich'd*), posting "crap" literally, protecting Saber, and denying accusations of being Swiss.
Astral: For the blind following of accusation of spy conspiracy, using the 'first post' theory, and being Astral (what? I ran out of accusations, sorry).
Sims: For still having a creepy avatar.

Now now people, don't forget that if Silver is thought to be the spy, the mafia would want him alive so that they can pull the "fake spy" thing on him and get him out of the way that way. The spy can only convince the people that someone is the mafia if the people are willing to be convinced, and if the mafia can convince them not to be convinced which is easy in a game of mistrust, they can beat the crowd and win the round.

The above listings are not, as they appear, a listing of every random thing people have done, but the minute details that may be the mafia's disguise, in chronological order, all could be possibly incriminating, down to Cheez's crap. Look for discrepancies, oddities, or otherwise suspicious activities, and you will find, I think, that the list is way too long... I mean- you will find that one of the most suspicious people is Cheez! *cop-out answer*

[Phonox]

Unless, that was just to throw us off your trail, then you killed Gar the next round to show her innocence, and proclaim yourself innocent as well!

Anyway, here's a list.

Phonox - Witch
Saber
Josiah
Silver - Spy (85%) Mafia(15%)
Poik - Normie (Doctors and Mafias can't pick themselves, right?)
Cheez
Astral

That's all I'm sure of right now. Silver's probably a spy. A bad one.

[Cheezdude]

Cheez: For blind followings of the previous posters, accusations of spy conspiracy, use of third person, hesitation in a war zone, claiming that Poik could help in the slightest, using because as the first word in a sentence and forgetting the necessary comma (grammar theory!), rhyming (rhyming theory *sanwich'd*), posting "crap" literally, protecting Saber, and denying accusations of being Swiss.

I laughed so hard at that Poik. You just won the game (which everyone else just lost).

[Siranae]

Unless Siranae is pronounced differently, I believe Cheez just rhymed. Is there a rhyming theory?

I think we talked about this a while ago in the Saying Hi to Josiah thread. But, I don't want you to have to go through the past pages, so I'll just tell you here. Siranae is pronounced Sear-a-nay. You're not the only one who was confused by that, seeing as it's a made up word.

[Simsmagic]

Phonox -
Saber - Silver
Josiah - Saber
Silver - Saber
Poik -
Cheez - Silver
Astral - Poik

There's a spoon in my ear.

[Astral Omega]

I vote Poik on grounds of his post being a large dish of copypasta with a few extra spices, but still basically the same thing.

[PoikSpirit]

You're just mad because I'm not incriminating you that much Astral.

Anyway, yeah, I forgot. I still pronounce most things as if they're Latin when I first see them. And from then on until I'm corrected (twice it would seem).

[Josiah]

And I tend to pronounce most strange words using Japanese vowel sounds.

For the record: I can't actually read PMs unless they're sent to me. The mafia can not kill himself (it'd make for a lame game). The spy can not spy on himself (no point). But the doctor can save himself (pretty selfish doctor, but it is allowed).

[Cheezdude]

We have 2112 posts in this thread.

[PoikSpirit]

Well I knew that, but do you have to take the fun out of everything Josiah?

Just kidding. Some of the new members may not, in fact, know that.

Also, there's a banana in my ear. Beat that.

[Cheezdude]

I vote that Poik should vote.